QuickTopic logo Create New TopicNew Topic My TopicsMy Topics News
Zarthani.net banner

H. Beam Piper Mailing List and Discussion Forum

NOTICE: QuickTopic is shutting down soon. Learn more.
Skip to Messages
Welcome to the Zarthani.net H. Beam Piper mailing list and discussion forum. Initiated in October 2008 (after the demise of the original PIPER-L mailing list), this tool for shared communication among Piper fans provides an e-mail list and a discussion forum with on-line archives.
 
Membership in this moderated list/forum is by invitation only. (If you'd like an invitation please request one by sending a message to the Moderator.) In order for your messages to be approved for posting to the list you must be both registered with the QuickTopic site (click the "Sign In" link at the top-right of the page) and subscribed to receive messages from the list by e-mail (click the "Get email" button below).
 
Moderation will focus on keeping the discussion related to H. Beam Piper in a broadly interpreted sense. Off-topic posts or ad hominem comments will not be approved for posting and repeat offenders may be banned from posting to the list.
 
There is an annual subscription fee required to keep this list/forum free of advertisements and to provide expanded functionality such as the capability to post images. You can support the continued ad-free availability of this shared resource by making a contribution using the PayPal link at the top of the page. (You don't need a PayPal account to make a donation, just a credit card.) Thank you for whatever level of support you can afford.
^     All messages    << 786-801  755-785 of 2246  739-754 >>
785
Jackson Russell
12-31-2010
23:57 UT
Hey! Who U callin a zombie? I got military grade protection here!
Zombie! Hmph!

braaaiiins...

Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
784
Jim "Rhino" SparrPerson was signed in when posted
12-31-2010
22:46 UT
I believe that this thing is a viral spambot that infests your computer, and then sends trash out to the internet. Something similar can steal your e-mail ID and then use it even after you've rooted the virus out. It sends the data to where it came from. I know this because I keep getting spammed from one of my Yahoo contacts, who's scrubbed her computer and changed her account.

I know it isn't going through mine because I follow tight security procedures, check my logs, use a dialup connection, and the times are wrong, "but what about all you zombies?"

Check your computers, folks. It found this site somehow.
783
David Johnson
12-31-2010
16:25 UT
~
Jack,

> Who is this Pharmf guy with multiple e-dresses that keeps
> spamming us?


A robot, most likely. I can delete the posts from the forum and ban them afterwards but obviously it's figured a way around that by using the multiple IP addresses.

Again, let me urge everyone reading this to "Subscribe" using the button the on the discussion archive page (there should be a link in this message). We may soon move to subscription-only to avoid the spamming.

If you have difficulties subscribing--or are not sure if you're already subscribed--drop me a note off-list at "piperfan (at)
zarthani (dot) net" and I'll help you sort it out.

Thanks,

David
--
"[Computers] can't imagine, they can't create, and they can't do anything a human brain can't." - Conn Maxwell (H. Beam Piper),
"Graveyard of Dreams"
~
782
Jackson Russell
12-31-2010
16:00 UT
Who is this Pharmf guy with multiple e-dresses that keeps spamming us?
Jack

< replied-to message removed by QT >
  Messages 781-779 deleted by author 12-31-2010 10:14 AM
778
MMoeser237@aol.com
12-29-2010
23:16 UT
Hello David -- I'd like to contribute, but I don't paypal. Alternatives? Mark
 
 
 
 
 
In a message dated 12/27/2010 12:07:02 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, qtopic-42-tnfVKeAH3s4T@quicktopic.com writes:

Please
considering making a donation, in any amount, to support this
resource for the Piper fan community by using the PayPal link
at the top of the discussion forum page:
777
Spam deleted by QuickTopic 10-28-2012 07:16
776
David Johnson
12-25-2010
07:20 UT
~
David "Lensman" Sooby wrote:

> It has been pointed out
> that human activity does influence weather
> patterns. Drain a swamp *here*, it decreases humidity *there*.

Indeed, Beam himself portrays these sorts of impacts on Zarathustra. (Different setting/universe, I realize, but it's clear he recognized this sort of thing.)

> It seems
> to me this is somewhat related to a trend in the THFH series
> much discussed on the two fan forums, regarding stories which
> seem to point to a rise of a new local or regional galactic
> civilization even while the old galactic civilization was
> crumbling: /The Cosmic Computer/ and /The Space Viking/. As
> has been pointed out, stories set in later eras make no mention
> of these new civilizations, so we must assume they failed to
> live up to their early promises. This suggests to me that Piper
> assumed a large amount of historical inevitability; call it fate
> or destiny, if you wish.

I think Beam was just a pessimist when it comes to human
civilization. Call it "historical entropy." (It also seems he enjoyed this sort of hook: ending a yarn on a hopeful note, then jumping ahead some years to a point where those hopes have been lost in the past.)

> This is not to suggest that the THFH series is one timeline in
> Paratime. It *is* to suggest that because they had the same
> author, we can find similar themes in both series.

I agree with Lensman. ;)

>> or that Fifth Level has many timelines while no intelligence
>> worth mentioning exists there?
>
>
> More specifically: No intelligence worth mentioning exists or
> ever existed on *earth*. I'm pretty sure it's stated in the
> stories that those are the result of various decisions and
> actions by Martians which lead to no human colonization of
> Earth. Apparently it was most likely that the Martians died
> out, leaving no descendants, and the colonization of Earth was
> a low-probability event.

Or even more specifically, no "Martio-human" intelligence exists on Earth _within_ the "range" of Fifth Level timelines explored by the Paratimers. Because they begin with the premise that civilization on Earth results from colonization from Mars their reach across Fifth Level is going to focus on those timelines where that possibility existed. Indeed, the Paratimers are exploiters not explorers and so they really have no need to venture across Fifth Level farther than they need to collect resources, develop vacation spots, and place cross-time work areas. It may be that the Paratimers have only ever visited a minority of all Fifth Level timelines. . . .

(I think we also have a continuity problem in that Beam seemed to be backing away from the Martian origins of First Level civilization in later Paratime yarns. . . .)

David
--
"It would be natural for me to supply details for the future.
But . . . a lot of this stuff is based on unpredictable and arbitrary factors that can't be inferred from anything in the present." - Edward Chalmers (H. Beam Piper), "The Edge of the Knife"

~
775
David Johnson
12-25-2010
07:04 UT
~
Jim Rhino Sparr wrote:

> I do however note that if you
> cruised far enough beyond described Fifth Level,sooner or later
> the earth mass, lunar mass, solar mass, lunar distance, solar
> distance, etc., would diverge from our local observed values.

Perhaps so, but the really interesting thing about Fifth Level is that long before you got to the timelines where the differences were on a geological--or astronomical!--scale there might be some pretty interesting differences on an evolutionary scale (like those
mentioned in the "Theropod" discussion a while back).

David
--
"You know any kind of observation that doesn't contaminate the thing observed, professor?" - Tortha Karf (H. Beam Piper),
_Lord_Kalvan_of_Otherwhen_
~
774
Lensman
12-25-2010
04:39 UT
On 12/24/2010 9:21 PM, QT - Jim Rhino Sparr wrote:
> what about the scene where Vall is watching the trees move
> around randomly between timelines,

Two possibilities:

One: The different placement of trees was a result of human activity. Frex trees have been planted all throughout the Midwest in America, where they never grew before. Even in old growth forests, logging would affect exactly where trees grow.

Two: My own personal fan theory is that we must assume a certain amount of low-level variation between the different inhabited timelines. Think of it as a version of quantum uncertainty writ on the macro scale. It has been pointed out that human activity does influence weather
patterns. Drain a swamp *here*, it decreases humidity *there*. It is said that overgrazing exacerbated the spread of the Sahara... altho recently it's been suggested human influence may have been exaggerated, and that the desertification was primarily due to natural climate change.
But as I said in my previous post, we must assume there is some force, some factor which, over time, slowly but inexorably damps out the differences between closely adjacent timelines over time. Or in the case of the weather, not slowly at all, but rather rapidly!**
(Presumably this force weakens over distance across Paratime, so that more distant timelines can be more different.) It seems to me this is somewhat related to a trend in the THFH series much discussed on the two fan forums, regarding stories which seem to point to a rise of a new local or regional galactic civilization even while the old galactic civilization was crumbling: /The Cosmic Computer/ and /The Space Viking/. As has been pointed out, stories set in later eras make no mention of these new civilizations, so we must assume they failed to live up to their early promises. This suggests to me that Piper assumed a large amount of historical inevitability; call it fate or destiny, if you wish. Local variances, no matter how promising, get damped out over time by the tide of historical inevitability.

Even in /Lord Kalvan of Otherwhen/, note it is stated that the House of Styphon is inevitably doomed to fall. Kalvan's actions merely cause it to fall somewhat earlier on one timeline.

This is not to suggest that the THFH series is one timeline in Paratime. It *is* to suggest that because they had the same author, we can find similar themes in both series.

> or that Fifth Level has many timelines while no intelligence worth
> mentioning exists there?

More specifically: No intelligence worth mentioning exists or ever existed on *earth*. I'm pretty sure it's stated in the stories that those are the result of various decisions and actions by Martians which lead to no human colonization of Earth. Apparently it was most likely that the Martians died out, leaving no descendants, and the colonization of Earth was a low-probability event. Earth exists on all the timelines which have a Mars-- or at least, all those explored by Paratimers. But since Earth was not colonized on most of those timelines, there is no influence of intelligent activity on the myriad Earths, hence they are all exactly the same. An explorer would find the same situation if he visited Jupiter or Venus on those timelines: They would all be exactly alike.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

**Perhaps our understanding of Chaos theory is all wrong. Perhaps what we see as "islands of stability" in probability are situations where local conditions prevail-- that is, conditions existing only on an individual timeline are the primary factors of cause and effect-- but in other situations or areas of probability, areas where theory says chaos reins, perhaps this is an indication that cross-timeline similarity prevails. If so, then even the name "Chaos theory" is completely wrong-- it's exactly backwards. We only *see* it as chaos-- complete randomness-- because we can only see one timeline, and thus can't see the influence of the nearly infinite number of other timelines.

I only just thought of this, but I rather like it. It would explain why weather is the same across Paratime-- if weather is particularly influenced by what *we* see as random chance, the "strange attractors" of Chaos theory, then that means in actuality it's particularly
influenced by crosstime similarity, which would explain why weather is the same from one end of (explored) Paratime to the other. This fan theory needs a name, though. The opposite of Chaos-- perhaps the Iron Law of Crosstime Similarity?

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
773
Jim "Rhino" SparrPerson was signed in when posted
12-25-2010
03:21 UT
Okay, but what about the scene where Vall is watching the trees move around randomly between timelines, or that Fifth Level has many timelines while no intelligence worth mentioning exists there?

Does anyone know if Beam was aware of Everett's many-worlds formulation of quantum mechanics? I think Campbell referred to it in /Astounding/. That could have some bearing here.
772
Lensman
12-24-2010
16:02 UT
On 12/23/2010 10:24 PM, QT - Jim Broshot wrote:

> Query: would the eclipse prediction tables for the present time
> line work on the other time lines? Like Paratimers could use
> them to intimidate the natives?

Yes. Continents are the same, and-- according to one story-- even the weather patterns are the same from one end of Paratime to the other. This indicates all purely natural forces result in the same outcome on all timelines. Apparently only decisions made by intelligent life result in different timelines. And probably even then, only a very small number of decisions actually result in divergence. (This is best explained if we assume there is some force damping the divergence between timelines close to each other; some factor or force must be working to counteract the natural tendency toward exponentially
increasing divergence over time, as predicted by Chaos theory.)

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
771
Jim "Rhino" SparrPerson was signed in when posted
12-24-2010
05:25 UT
Jim, I've been meditating on my last response and want to modify it slightly. Yes, the eclipse tables should work on any timeline Piper wrote about. I do however note that if you cruised far enough beyond described Fifth Level,sooner or later the earth mass, lunar mass, solar mass, lunar distance, solar distance, etc., would diverge from our local observed values. The tables would fail in such a universe.
770
Jim "Rhino" SparrPerson was signed in when posted
12-24-2010
04:48 UT
Yes, barring some effect we Fourth Level critters don't yet know about, Solar System orbital mechanics should be the same on all of the timelines.

BTW, "Merry Christmas to all, and to all a good night".
769
Spam deleted by QuickTopic 10-28-2012 07:16
768
Jim "Rhino" SparrPerson was signed in when posted
12-24-2010
04:02 UT

What my LX10, Fuji S1 and I did on the solstice. Enjoy.
767
Jon
12-23-2010
18:19 UT
Oh I knew that it wasn't a Christmas song, but I figured that was as close as I'd get to a Christmassy reference with Piper!

Unless they mentioned the winter solstice holiday in Temple Trouble, and I don't think good wishes from a crocadile-rabbit-chicken-whatever hybrid was really appropriate. "Happy Holidays and watch out for the sharp teeth!!" seemed a bit of a surreal stretch...
766
David Johnson
12-23-2010
16:58 UT
~
Jim "Rhino" Sparr wrote:

> Jon, your sentiments are appreciated, but I believe that the
> "barbarian chant" was intended to mean. . . .


Hey, a Fourth Level barbarian chant is a Fourth Level barbarian chant . . . and the sentiment is much appreciated. :)

Merry Solstice (a cross-time holiday!),

David
--
"Our rulers are the barbarians among us. There isn't one of
them . . . who is devoted to civilization or anything else outside himself, and that's the mark of the barbarian." - Otto Harkaman (H. Beam Piper), _Space_Viking_
~
765
Jim "Rhino" SparrPerson was signed in when posted
12-23-2010
16:29 UT
Jon, your sentiments are appreciated, but I believe that the "barbarian chant" was intended to mean "For He's a Jolly Good Fellow", rather than "Auld Lang Syne", as the occasion being celebrated was Tortha's retirement and Verkan's promotion. Its occurring on Year End Day (NOT New Year's)was incidental.
764
Jon
12-23-2010
16:09 UT
Merry Christas & a Happy New Year to all!

"...and then they'd break into that Fourth Level barbarian chant they used on these occasions." - Lord Kalvan, last chapter
763
David Johnson
12-20-2010
00:18 UT
~
"Rebel Raider" original on eBay

The original publication of Beam's historical fiction yarn, "Rebel Raider," published in the December 1950 issue of ~True~ magazine is available on eBay (at a reasonable price):

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=310274051810

Good luck!

David
--
"[T]here was a bimbo just made to be leered at, and she probably resented it like hell if she weren't." - H. Beam Piper,
_Murder_in_the_Gunroom_
~
  Messages 762-761 deleted by author 12-16-2010 12:53 AM
760
David Johnson
12-10-2010
16:03 UT
~
Apologies for the unwelcome messages from the Piper List this
morning. I've blocked those users but the messages came from four different IP addresses so we may see some more. If that continues I may have to limit posting only to registered subscribers. If you've not subscribed already please consider doing so now. If you're not sure how to do that contact me off-line at piperfan (at) zarthani (dot) net.

David
--
"[Computers] can't imagine, they can't create, and they can't do anything a human brain can't." - Conn Maxwell (H. Beam Piper),
"Graveyard of Dreams"
~
  Spam messages 759-755 deleted by QuickTopic between 12-10-2010 10:56 AM and 01-24-2014 01:09 AM
754
Lensman
11-28-2010
20:28 UT
On 11/28/2010 2:14 PM, QT - Tom Rogers wrote:
> The problem with text communication (like this
> list) is that much meaningful nuance is lost

Yeah, that's the problem. But no harm, no foul. Or as Miss Emily Litella said: "Nevermind!"

And thanks for your reply.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Clear ether!
Lensman

Visit the Incompleat Known Space Concordance at:
http://www.freewebs.com/knownspace/
^     All messages    << 786-801  755-785 of 2246  739-754 >>

Print | RSS Views: 35310 (Unique: 9358 ) / Subscribers: 27 | What's this?